I like her work and after seeing the trailer of this set I was really curious how this set would turn out.
If you missed the trailer you can watch it here in all its beauty:
So lets break this thing down. I think you can divide it into some rough chapters without going tooo much into detail. A pretty good idea so we will start with *drum roll*...
Chapter 1 - Getting ready:
The first chapter starts with a short introduction of Natalya. At this stage she says one sentence you will remember at the end (not original quote): "After watching this you won't paint like Natalya but you see how I do it and hopefully it will help you improve painting". She then goes over explaining which tools, brushes, primers, basing materials and paints she uses.
Chapter 2 - Preparation:
Chapter 2 talks about cleaning, priming, pinning and the general preparation of a miniature. In the first part the miniature is freed of mold lines and is prepared for pinning. Natalya then shows how she uses modelling putty to prepare the surface of the miniature. If the video is sped up, you see it by a "2x" logo in the video. That seems to be the fastest it gets accelerated therefore you can watch looooong periods of greenstuff or pinning work without even some comment.
At around timemark 42 min she starts priming the miniature.
Chapter 3 - Basic painting:
This part starts with a basic coloring example of dwarf skin. Although it is titled "basic painting" it is nowhere near a beginners advice how to do that. The skin color is mixed, layered and blended directly on the miniature. The explanations somehow is a bit funny "in the shades I use darker brown" "on the highlights I use lighter color". Who would have thought of THAT!
After 45 minutes of applying the base skin tone, the miniature is switched (a female miniature) and again the skin is painted. This lasts about 60 minutes until she then starts to paint the leather boots and accessoires! Yes it is really impressive how the skin looks after this period of time especially when you think that she started with a dark brown and now is on a pretty light skin tone but well...
After another hour we go a bit more into the details. Painting of the hair! And of the cloak. Cheerio! You can watch it again for around an hour, speed it up or just switch to the next chapter...
Meanwhile another teaser to ease up the wall of text:
Chapter 4 - Painting Faces, NMM, Freehands
Again two miniatures are used as example for painting faces. The already known dwarf and a female miniature. For me the dwarf part is not really interesting. The part where she paints the female face is pretty nice because she explains why she does this and that coloring. And the brushwork is absolutely insane!
After 45 minutes the NMM part starts. It shows metallic and gold NMM and was the first thing in this set that helped me understand the principal theory behind NMM a bit better.
The freehands sadly come later in the next chapter. But until now this was the best chapter so far.
Chapter 5 - Watch me painting a complete figure
Yep you can trust your eyes. We can now watch Natalya paint a complete miniature! Or we can hit the fast forward and save us nearly 6 hours of "I paint teclis" footage. If this should be an instruction video? Well I think we speak different languages here...
Conclusio
Perhaps you have already read it from my comments but am I "exited" about this DVD? Let me start with a quote from the set description:
Learn how to paint like an international winner! See every brush stroke, and fully understand by watching the complete process. You will never see another tutorial like this!
Learn how to paint like [...]: Let's see... NO! How if the basics are not explained and even the really expert stuff isn't. In my opinion you can learn more by watching Youtube tutorials...
See every brush stroke [...]: Aehm jep. Every stroke. For hours and hours until I fell asleep or find the 128x speed button on me remote... The set would be much better if the painting process would be accelerated by more than two times (and that not often enough).
You will never see another tutorial like this!: Right! Such crap is hardly to produce a second time. If you even could call it a tutorial.
Would I buy this DVD set? Definitely NO! I am really happy that I only borrowed it for watching. After some time the music really gets on your nerves, the 13 hours of "instruction" are only a bad joke and for improving there are way too few explanations how the stuff is done. The 50 bucks could be spent much better. Either for a nice dinner with your beloved one or for another DVD set of your choice. Perhaps I am a too bad painter to understand the Secrets of Natalya but (as much as I like the results of her work) I think the DVD is only to get some cash flowing...
If you wonder which DVD you should spend the money on, just wait a bit, I have something up my sleeve for you :)
Hope this was somewhat helpful for you. If you have a different opinion of if I have missed something, please state it in the comments.
So long,
Paradoxon
P.S.: Sorry for this massive wall of text. I first wanted to include some screencaps of the video but wasn't sure if I violate the copyrights. I think so: therefore no pictures. Instead I tried to work with the official video stuff from CMON...
Thanks for the review. I have thought about some of these but been nervous that the things you pointed out about this one would be the case. Perhaps the title should be "Watching Natalya paint".
ReplyDeleteYep that would be much more fitting.
DeleteI have also the "Miniature Painting Secrets with Jen" here and some other DVD and will do a review about them too. So just wait a few days, maybe you'll find a better set to buy (I don't say which until the review *G*).
Heh.. Nice review Paradox0n. Was concerned about this one, and am glad I haven't picked it up for all the points you mentioned. Perhaps only the NMM theory section would also be useful for me as well, but then again I don't care too much for NMM at the moment so :)
ReplyDeleteHave to say that I hope you get the chance to see some of the Miniature Mentor videos. They are ace in a lot of ways, and really go into the whys a lot more. Some are easier to watch than others, I guess I should do reviews of them as well one day!
Looking forward to reading the review of Jen's video! A local around my parts ( before she moved down south! ). So curious if it is better/worse or the same!
Thanks!
DeleteJep the Miniature Mentor ones also cought me eye. Maybe I'll do a test purchase of one of the basic tutorials. We'll see :)
Without spoiling too much: You can't compare the two sets (Natalya and Jen) they play in different leagues imo. Stay tuned Jens is in work and will hopefully be ready to the weekend:)
Btw: The third will be the first set from Jeremie.
Thanks for a great review.
ReplyDeleteI'd have been tempted by the tag "15 hours of instructions from a golden demaon winner" but totally agree that I do not consider 6 hours of watching someone else paint as instructional, wold just be a waste that I would fast forward through.I could sit down and watch rugby all day, would be no better at kicking a conversion at the end of it though...
If I could ask one thing, can you say in your future reviews what range of paints the tutorial mainly use. I know pro painters use a mix of all the paint ranges, but my lack of imagination means I don't want to shell out $50 on tutorials that use mainly P3 paints when all mine are Vallejo. Look forward to your other reviews :-)
Thanks for your comment :)
DeleteSince the painters mostly use every color they seem fit, that would be a bit complicated ^^ But I can try IF they prefer a specific brand.
In my opinion it really doesn't matter which paint they use, you can transfer the tips to all different brands. I use GW and Vallejo colors and have no problems following instructions in all the different video tutorials I have seen so far.
Sounds dreadful. Thank you for taking one for the team.
ReplyDeletejordan 1 off white
ReplyDeletemoncler
bape hoodie
curry shoes
kyrie 5 spongebob
moncler coat
yeezy shoes
curry shoes
paul george shoes
golden goose